Is Your Business Ready For Auditing In The Age Of ESG?

Introduction

Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) has rapidly moved from the periphery to the heart of corporate strategy and accountability. No longer just a buzzword, ESG now shapes how businesses are audited, funded, reported on and regulated. This shift means that traditional auditing is evolving. While general ESG reporting may involve both internal and external audits (often voluntarily), AASB S2 reporting mandates external audit assurance, placing a significant emphasis on the reliability and comparability of climate-related financial information, with internal audit playing a crucial supporting role in building the necessary internal controls and processes. Although mandatory sustainability reporting in Australia currently applies only to larger companies and organisations, SMEs shouldn’t assume they’re off the hook. ESG requirements are expected to extend to a broader range of businesses in the near future, and many SMEs are already being asked to provide ESG data by the larger organisations they supply. With new regulations, heightened investor expectations, and a global push for standardisation, understanding ESG auditing is crucial for staying compliant and competitive. 

Key ESG Considerations in Audits

Specialist ESG auditors examine how well a business manages risks and opportunities across three pillars:

• Environmental: This covers carbon emissions, sustainability practices, waste management, and energy efficiency. Auditors will assess how your business measures, manages, and reports on these factors, including greenhouse gas emissions across your supply chain. 
• Social: Diversity and inclusion, workplace safety, community engagement, and human rights compliance are under the spotlight. For example, modern slavery risks in supply chains are now a key audit focus, with businesses needing to demonstrate robust policies and transparent reporting.
• Governance: Board diversity, ethical business practices, anti-corruption measures, and executive compensation are scrutinised. Auditors look for evidence that governance structures support ethical behaviour and effective risk management.

Recent Regulatory Changes

Australian ESG compliance is entering a new era, driven by important and sweeping regulatory changes:

• Climate-Related Financial Disclosures: Large and medium-sized companies and financial institutions must comply with new Australian Sustainability Reporting Standards (ASRS). These standards align closely with global frameworks, such as the IFRS International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB). The AASB S2 standard requires companies to disclose climate risks, emissions (Scope 1, 2, and 3), and transition plans. These disclosures are now law for entities meeting certain thresholds, with phased implementation from 2025.
• Nature-Related Financial Disclosures: While currently voluntary, frameworks like the Taskforce for Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD) are gaining traction. Australian businesses are encouraged to start reporting on biodiversity and natural resource impacts in anticipation of future requirements.

Impact on Business Auditing

Integration of ESG in Audit Processes

Auditing is no longer just about financial statements. ESG auditing is now being integrated into both internal and external audit plans. Auditors are assessing your ESG risks, controls, and reporting alongside traditional financial audits, creating a more holistic view of business performance and risk exposure. This integration means audit materiality assessments now include ESG issues, ensuring companies focus on the most relevant risks and opportunities for their specific business and stakeholder base.

Auditors are also tasked with evaluating the systems and processes you use to capture, verify, and report ESG metrics. This includes assessing data collection methodologies, internal controls over ESG reporting, and the reliability of third-party data sources. The scrutiny extends beyond direct operations to encompass third-party due diligence and supply chain resilience, holding companies accountable for ESG risks throughout their value chain. This means even SMEs that aren’t yet subject to mandatory ESG reporting requirements may find themselves under scrutiny as part of larger companies’ supply chain assessments, making ESG preparedness crucial regardless of current reporting obligations.

[Watch our Financial Reporting Update Webinar – navigate to 01:20:17 for Sustainability Reporting]

Governance and Culture

Strong governance has now become a board-level responsibility, and auditors are evaluating whether boards and executives align ESG objectives with overall business strategy and risk management frameworks. This assessment examines decision-making processes, resource allocation for ESG initiatives, and the integration of sustainability considerations into strategic planning.

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) is increasing scrutiny of sustainability claims, with auditors playing a crucial role in ensuring ESG disclosures are credible and substantiated. This enhanced oversight means businesses must maintain robust evidence to support their ESG claims and be prepared for detailed audits.

Stakeholder Engagement

Your stakeholders today, particularly your investors, demand independent assurance over ESG disclosures. They want confidence that sustainability claims are accurate, methodologies are sound, and reporting aligns with regulatory requirements and stakeholder expectations.

This highlights the crucial role auditors play, by providing this assurance through reviewing ESG reporting methodologies, testing data accuracy, and evaluating the effectiveness of ESG management systems. This independent verification helps build stakeholder trust and provides the credibility needed to attract investment and maintain market confidence.

How Your Business Can Prepare for ESG Audits

Successful ESG audit preparation requires proactive planning and systematic implementation across your organisation. 

1. Start by establishing clear ESG policies and goals that align with your business strategy and stakeholder expectations. These policies should be specific, measurable, and supported by robust governance structures that ensure accountability and oversight.
2. Implement internal ESG reporting mechanisms that can capture accurate, timely, and relevant data across environmental, social, and governance dimensions. This includes investing in systems and processes that can withstand audit scrutiny and provide the transparency that stakeholders demand.
3. Collaborate with your auditors for proactive ESG compliance rather than reactive problem-solving. Early engagement helps identify potential issues, align expectations, and develop reporting frameworks that meet both regulatory requirements and business needs.

Consider conducting regular internal ESG assessments to identify gaps and opportunities before formal audits. This proactive approach helps build confidence in your ESG reporting and demonstrates genuine commitment to sustainability objectives. Also consider proactively monitoring updates to ESG reporting standards and prepare for phased increases in reporting and assurance requirements. Early compliance not only avoids penalties, but also demonstrates leadership to your investors and stakeholders. 

The Way Forward

The age of ESG auditing is here, and for Australian businesses, the stakes have never been higher. With mandatory ESG reporting and disclosures now in effect for all larger companies, and soon to include mid-sized enterprises, integrating ESG considerations into your audit strategy is essential, not just for compliance, but for long-term resilience and reputation. The businesses that will thrive in this new environment are those who embrace ESG integration as a strategic advantage rather than a compliance burden. They’re building robust systems, engaging proactively with auditors, and using ESG considerations to drive better business decisions and stakeholder outcomes.

Want to know more about how Bentleys can help you?

Contact Bentleys today for a consultation with one of our expert tax advisors who can offer tailored advice specific to your industry, business structure, and growth ambitions. With the right strategic tax partner, you can turn tax management from a necessary obligation into a competitive advantage. We’re here to help you get where you want to be.

Disclaimer: This information is general in nature and should not be relied on as advice. It does not take into account the objectives, financial situation or needs of any particular person. You need to consider your financial situation and needs and seek professional advice before making any decisions based on this information.