You Made A Loss, So Why Is There A Tax Bill?
Opinion | Tax & Business
An unintended outcome in Australia’s new capital gains tax law, passed in June 2026 and applying from 1 July 2027, means some individuals could still face a tax bill after a genuine loss. Andrew Keily explains the anomaly, and why understanding where you stand matters.
Imagine generating tax losses in a business and carrying them forward over a number of years. They’re genuine, painful, cash-out-the-door losses. Then you find you may still owe the ATO 30% when you use them to offset a capital gain. It’s something we’ve noticed working through the changes to capital gains tax law. It’s exactly the kind of outcome some individuals with tax losses could find themselves facing. And for a profession built on the idea that everything balances, that’s a hard one to reconcile.
One of the things I’ve always liked about accounting is its simplicity. Every debit has a credit. Everything balances. There’s usually a quiet sense of fairness in the way the numbers work. When I joined the profession back in 2005, the legislation felt balanced. You could look a client in the eye and explain why they were paying what they were paying.
The balance is getting harder to find
Lately, though, that balance feels harder to find. People are wrestling with rising costs, staff shortages, more regulation and a constant stream of legislative change. My phone has never rung more than it did through Covid. Clients fired off question after question, only for the rules to change again the following week. Planning for the future is hard enough without the rules changing halfway through the game. I’ve been using the analogy of playing cricket and after lunch you come back onto the MCG only to find out the game has been changed to AFL and you are wearing full pads.
An anomaly the drafters probably didn’t intend
One outcome in the new law has received very little attention. My guess is it was never the intention, but it could have real consequences for some individuals. That makes it worth putting under the spotlight. Under the traditional approach, the maths was intuitive. Say an individual made a capital gain of $100,000 and also had revenue losses of $100,000. The two effectively offset each other. No net income, no tax payable. Fair enough. I think most people would agree that’s the right result, because you haven’t actually made an economic profit.
Under the new law, the outcome can look very different. Take the same example. The individual uses $100,000 of revenue losses against $100,000 of post 1 July 2027 capital gains. The result is nil taxable income. Even with no overall economic profit, the individual will still pay $30,000 in tax on the capital gain. That’s a result of the new 30% minimum tax on capital gains. The individual also uses up the losses.
My guess is this isn’t a deliberate design choice, more an anomaly that’s fallen through the cracks while the focus was on the bigger changes to the discount and the rate. It wouldn’t happen, for instance, if a trust generated the same revenue losses and capital gain. The trust offsets them before distributing to an individual beneficiary. In this case the minimum tax wouldn’t apply.
Using the super contributions strategy as an example
There’s a second place where I think this outcome could catch people out, and it involves super. A common way to manage a large capital gain, say from selling a property, is to make a personal deductible super contribution in the same year.
Here’s how the maths has traditionally worked. Say someone has a $100,000 capital gain and makes a $100,000 deductible contribution using bring forward rules. The deduction and the gain wipe each other out for income tax purposes, and the money goes into super, where the fund pays 15% contributions tax.
Under the new law, the picture will look very different. The 30% minimum tax still applies to the gain even with the deduction in place, meaning $30,000 is payable on the gain. Add the 15% contributions tax on the $100,000 contribution, which is $15,000, and the total comes to $45,000. The strategy is now no longer an option.
It’s a reminder that a strategy that has worked well under the old rules may need a fresh look before the new ones start. If you’ve been planning to sell an asset and use catch-up contributions, talk to your Bentleys adviser before you commit.
Understand your position
So if there’s one thing I’d urge you to do after reading this, it’s to raise it with your adviser at your next review. Not because there’s a straightforward fix, but because understanding how this could affect you removes the surprise. Ask the direct question: could this apply to me? Ask your adviser to walk through how your gains and losses would interact under the new rules, so you know what to expect rather than finding out when your return is prepared. If you hold your investments through a trust or company rather than in your own name, the rules differ, see our related article on the minimum tax on discretionary trusts for that side of it. Paying tax after making a genuine economic profit is one thing, paying tax after making a loss is a far harder outcome to accept, and being unaware makes it harder still.
If you’d value a hand understanding where you stand, our team at Bentleys can walk you through what these rules mean for you.
Important information
This article is general information only. It reflects the author’s views and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or particular needs, and it is not intended to be, and should not be relied on as, financial product advice, tax advice, legal advice or a recommendation to take (or not take) any course of action.
The measure discussed is now law under the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Act 2026, applying to capital gains realised on or after 1 July 2027. Tax outcomes depend on your individual circumstances. Before acting on anything in this article, you should seek advice tailored to your situation from a qualified Bentleys adviser.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
Send enquiry
We’d love to hear from you. Complete the form and someone from our team will contact you soon.
"*" indicates required fields